top of page

Local tribes ask Murkowski, Sullivan to halt major federal bill

3 hours ago
9 min read
The Chilkat Indian Village Tribal Office building in Klukwan. (Division of Community and Regional Affairs photo)
The Chilkat Indian Village Tribal Office building in Klukwan. (Division of Community and Regional Affairs photo)

By Will Steinfeld Chilkat Valley News


The Chilkoot Indian Association and Chilkat Indian Village have joined a large bloc of tribal nations and Indigenous organizations opposing sweeping federal permitting reform quickly advancing through Congress. 


In a letter last week, the two local tribes, along with 17 other Southeast tribes, pressed Alaska’s senators to oppose the bill as currently written, which they say is a serious threat to tribal sovereignty. 


“We will remember this vote,” tribal leaders wrote, a phrase they used more than once. “A great deal of legislation now before Congress, and more to come in the next, will need the support of Tribal Nations to move forward. The [Alliance of Sovereign Tribes of Southeast Alaska] and its member tribes will weigh every Senator’s vote on Title III as we decide which bills, and which members, we stand behind.”


The bill, called the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, or BAAJA, reshapes many of the environmental and historic preservation regulations that govern major federal projects.


Broadly, the bill seeks to make the permitting process quicker and projects harder to stop through litigation. In landmark environmental laws like the National Environmental Policy Act, or NEPA, it institutes deadlines for both federal agencies and stakeholder groups where previously there were none, limits standing for lawsuits and weakens the reach of court injunctions. The upshot of the legislation, both supporters and opponents say, is that it will become easier to build major infrastructure — specifically major energy infrastructure. 


That’s been hailed by some as a boon for building clean energy and connecting renewables to the grid. It’s also been supported by some oil and gas interest groups, who say the bill will make it easier to build fossil fuel pipelines. 


Opponents, however, say the bill will render important regulations toothless, and a core piece of that opposition has come from tribal entities.


Tribes say consultation threatened

Southeast tribes, and Indigenous groups nationwide, have specifically focused their advocacy on a section of the bill that would alter the National Historic Preservation Act, or NHPA. 


The NHPA contains Section 106, the legal language that, on projects with federal permitting, gives tribes and Alaska Native corporations the right to a process called consultation. 


In those consultations, federal agencies must meet with tribes to identify cultural resources that may be affected by a project, and how those effects may be mitigated, said Anchorage-based Native American Rights Fund senior attorney Wesley Furlong in an interview last week. The process applies to a broad range of projects with federal permitting or federal funding, including high-profile local ones like the Lutak Dock, Porcupine Road repairs, and Cascade Point construction. 


The Native American Rights Fund, a strident opponent of the permitting bill, and local tribal leaders, say such consultations are a uniquely important tool for having a say in lands tribes traditionally use or claim, even if they may not currently hold title to them. 


“Most Alaska Tribes have no reservation land base, and our ancestral territories and cultural resources lie across federal, state, Alaska Native Corporation, and private lands,” the letter from Southeast tribal leaders read. “Section 106 is often our only opportunity to identify impacts on lands we do not hold title to, and federally funded roads, energy, and broadband projects routinely cross our homelands.”


In an interview Monday, Chilkat Indian Village tribal council president Kimberley Strong pointed to Deer Rock, a site near Chilkoot Lake that was destroyed by state road construction roughly 20 years before tribal consultations were written into the NHPA. 


“Across the spectrum of time, there have been numerous significant cultural sites that have been desecrated throughout our valley,” Strong said. “With consultations, we can speak out before that happens and have our voices heard.”


The authors of the bill say it maintains these consultations, and may even strengthen their legal standing by writing procedures into statute, rather than administrative code. Many tribes strongly disagree, and the letter from the Southeast tribes writes that the bill would “reduce Tribal consultation to a procedural box-checking exercise.” 


The permitting bill seeks to apply to Section 106 many of the principles it applies elsewhere: faster reviews, narrower reviews, and less ability to halt reviews through lawsuits. 


Changes are set to be made at multiple steps along the consultation process. 


At its outset, a narrower range of projects would trigger mandatory Section 106 consultations in the first place. Now, save for a few exceptions, projects must have “substantial control” by the federal government to trigger a review, eliminating Section 106 requirements for projects in which the federal government is only involved in a funding capacity. 


Similar limitations could apply to projects somewhere in-between — projects that are only partially federally managed, Furlong said. 


For instance, the Chilkat Indian Village engaged in months of consultations with the federal Maritime Administration over the high-profile Lutak Dock rebuild. That project is federally funded, and requires federal permits including from the Army Corps of Engineers and under the Endangered Species Act, but is being built by the Haines Borough on Haines Borough land. 


Furlong said he could not speak to specific local projects, but under the draft legislation, projects with similar partial federal involvement might see consultations that only review certain pieces of the project. For instance, Furlong said, consultations on a project with federal permitting for pile driving might only review the effects of pile driving, rather than of the entire completed structure. 


The bill would reduce the reach of tribal consultations in other ways, including by narrowing the definition of an “adverse effect,” excluding “visual, atmospheric, or audible elements unless the visual, atmospheric, or audible element would have a direct impact on a historic property that would significantly diminish the eligible characteristics of the historic property.”


The bill sets deadlines for each step of the consultation process and limits the ability of lawsuits to stop projects over Section 106 complaints. 


It also allows federal agencies to move past the consultation process if “other considerations outweigh the consideration of historic preservation.”


In one section of the process, the bill requires agencies to solicit information from tribes, but doesn’t specifically use the word “consultation.” 


It’s a lot of legal text, with diverging interpretations on each side of the bill. But even seemingly marginal changes — like specific use of the word “consultation” — are “an utter evisceration of tribes’ ability to engage and be consulted,” Furlong argued. 


“Whether for nefarious reasons, or timeline reasons, or not enough staff, giving (agencies) the out, that they don’t have to do it, in my experience, means they won’t do it,” he said. “Consultation requires meaningful engagement in dialogue and a back and forth. In our experience, even when the law is explicit, agencies are looking for ways to undercut their obligation to consult.”


There’s some tension over just how powerful a tool Section 106 consultations already are. On the one hand, Furlong and Strong acknowledge that consultations have inherent limitations even now. 


For one, there’s nothing under the current law binding an agency to the content of a consultation, requiring them to do what a tribal entity asks. In the Lutak Dock rebuild, despite ongoing disagreement between the Chilkat Indian Village and the federal Maritime Administration over effects of the project, the agency ended consultations earlier this year.


At the same time, both Strong and Furlong argue that the consultations are a uniquely important tool. 

Said Strong, “It’s not a position of power, it’s a position of responsibility. To have our voices heard on projects that will cause damage, is of course our right to have, and our responsibility to carry.”


The reason a consultation without any binding power can still be a key tool, Furlong said, is partly because they don’t always involve a dispute.


“It’s a super important tool that allows tribes what can be a meaningful seat at the table,” he argued. “In my experience, when tribes are brought in early and meaningfully engaged, the vast majority are not trying to stop projects. They’re just making sure sacred places and cultural resources are protected.”


Washington D.C. negotiations continue

In meetings this fall between tribal leaders in the region, the permitting bill has been “at the top of the list,” Strong said Monday. 


“We had 19 of the 21 tribes of Southeast Alaska sign on to a joint letter to Congress. I think it’s unprecedented for our people of Southeast Alaska to be in such lockstep.” 


Strong said Southeast tribal leaders spoke to Sen. Lisa Murkowski’s staff at a recent meeting, and that some of the concerns they raised helped spur an amendment to the bill released last week. 


The Alaska Federation of Natives also passed a resolution urging Murkowski to amend the bill, though without the demand made by Southeast tribes to either completely eliminate parts of the bill changing the NHPA and Section 106, or vote against the bill.


In a Tuesday interview with Alaska Public Media, Murkowski said she had been contacted by Sealaska Heritage Institute president Rosita Worl, as well as the Tanana Chiefs Conference and the Central Council of Tlingit & Haida Indian Tribes of Alaska; about text in the original version of the bill that tightened definitions of tribal religious and cultural properties. 


Murkowski said the amendment she helped negotiate last week removed that restrictive language. 

Murkowski’s office did not respond directly to questions from the Chilkat Valley News this week, but the senator spoke to the amendment on the Senate floor Wednesday. 


“I think the NHPA needs to be modernized, but we also must take tribes’ concerns very seriously to ensure permitting reform doesn’t come at the expense of meaningful consultation or protection of sites of traditional religious or cultural importance,” she said. “We all worked together over a long period of time to make what I think are substantive changes to address those concerns.”


Strong, however, called the changes made in the amendment “marginal.” Major tribal organizations and advocacy groups nationwide echoed that statement, including the National Congress of American Indians as well as Furlong’s Native American Rights Fund. 


“[Last week’s amendments] don’t really change anything about the bill or our opposition, or frankly Indian Country’s opposition, to the bill,” Furlong said. “Our view, and I believe it’s shared by the vast, vast majority of Indian Country, is the manager’s amendment doesn’t get to the core issues with the bill.”


Murkowski has stated strong support for the bill as a whole, calling it “the most important bill for us to enact before the end of the year.”


“The permitting reform is needed and necessary because it puts in timelines for which your federal agencies need to operate so that it is not completely open-ended,” she told Alaska Public Media’s Lori Townsend. “It doesn’t get rid of your environmental protections, whether it’s the Clean Water Act, NEPA, ESA, but it does put in place a level of transparency.” 


In a Senate hearing last year on the NHPA, Murkowski said the Section 106 process should ensure “tribal voices are meaningfully heard.” But she also said the process, in Alaska specifically, “presents its own set of problems when you have even very smaller, low-impact projects that may then trigger Section 106 reviews across huge areas.”


As an example, she cited a recent Alaska Power & Telephone broadband project in Skagway that she said was largely derailed by requirements put forward by the National Park Service under the NHPA. 


Reached by phone this week, AP&T regulatory head Jason Custer agreed with Murkowski’s statements: the utility, due to input from the park service, had been required to hand-dig 500 pits to search for cultural and historic properties along a 1.7-mile route between Skagway and Dyea where it planned to lay fiber-optic cable. 


“Usually when we put in fiber we have a third-party culture resource monitor present, monitoring for any disturbance to cultural resources, and if there are any, they’re on scene to identify it,” Custer said. “That’s an efficient way to check and minimize disturbances. The (park service) wanted us to hand dig test pits going through the park, which seemed like a bigger disturbance than even laying the fiber … ultimately digging test pits across 20-some locations in Dyea was just not possible.” 


Murkowski called the Dyea project “an example of project risk that is very small, but you have essential infrastructure that’s effectively being halted” by review under the NHPA.


That view is shared by a complicated coalition of elected officials and private-sector groups backing the bill. 


In the Senate, procedural votes to advance the legislation have drawn unanimous or near-unanimous support from the Republican caucus, but have split the Democratic caucus. That includes 10 different delegations where one of a state’s Democratic senators has voted yes, and another has voted no. 


Supporters of the bill on the left say it’s necessary for any transition to clean energy and will lower energy costs. Rhode Island Democrat Sheldon Whitehouse, a sponsor of the bill, said it would be the nation’s “biggest implemented climate bill” if passed. 


Whitehouse and Democratic co-sponsor Martin Heinrich (New Mexico) argued in a news conference last week that permitting barriers and litigation disproportionately affect new, land-intensive renewable energy, which is often located far away from population centers, requiring long transmission lines. 


“Even with Trump administration pressure in favor of oil and gas, 90% of new grid applications are for renewables,” Whitehouse said during his comments. “The market is for clean energy. So when you open the gate and your clean energy has 90% minimum of the market, you have accomplished a very good thing.” 


Despite Democrats’ climate framing, some oil and gas industry groups have also thrown support behind the bill, saying projects like fossil fuel pipelines will also become cheaper and easier to build with permitting reform. 


The bill’s climate-focused supporters say that’s a necessary piece of a bipartisan compromise. But plenty of other large environmental groups have lined up against it, warning that renewable energy gains won’t outweigh environmental harms elsewhere in the bill. The Wilderness Society in a statement this month said “irreversible destruction [the bill] would cause to treasured places like the Arctic, the Boundary Waters, Bears Ears, and Chaco is simply not a reasonable or necessary tradeoff.”


As of Wednesday, the Senate was set to consider amendments ahead of a final vote expected this week. Numerous senators from Western states have expressed a desire to further address tribal concerns specifically, and California Democrat Adam Schiff has proposed an amendment to strike NHPA changes entirely, as Southeast tribes have asked, but the amendment has not yet reached a floor vote. 


• This article originally appeared in the Chilkat Valley News.

Cedar Clinic Ad 1.png
25HEC053_Radia_Ad_Graphic-Chelsea-300x25
rainbowfoodsad1.png
BFM Digital Ad-1.png
Ramada Ad PDF 7-10-26.png
CBJ Public Notice Web Tile 8.07.2026.png
Trust land office.jpg
Oct.14.png
JPM 2.png
Holiday Cheer (5).jpg
girl yeti spaceship juneau independent ad 2.jpeg
bottom of page