top of page

Who will stand up to the cruise industry?

8 hours ago
4 min read
Cruise ships in downtown Juneau on July 16, 2026. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Independent)
Cruise ships in downtown Juneau on July 16, 2026. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Independent)

By Logan Miller 


Everyone knows tourism in Juneau is a hot-button issue. 


But not everyone agrees on what, if anything, should be done about it. 


The Juneau Visitor Industry Task Force (VITF) has been accepting public comments on this issue for months, and recently adopted a new set of recommendations. 


Most of my fellow community members who commented were very diplomatic. They acknowledged the hard work of the VITF members. They used a measured tone to express their concerns. They made well-reasoned suggestions for common-sense limits. 


And they were almost entirely ignored. 


Very little has changed. Myself and dozens of other fed-up Juneauites have unfortunately wasted our time sending emails and comments to the VITF. The VITF issued hollow recommendations that maintain the status quo. 


The VITF is a sham. Although some of its members advocated for real limits, the group as a whole apparently operates under the bogus assumption that we need to balance the profits of cruise ship companies with our quality of life. 


This should come as no surprise, because the vice-chair of the VITF is a high-up manager working for Princess Cruises and Holland America who has been described as “the face of the [cruise] industry in Juneau.” 


For decades, this same person simultaneously served as the director for shore operations for Princess Cruises and as the manager of the initiative that sets Juneau’s tourism standards. I can’t think of a more obvious example of the fox guarding the henhouse. 


The VITF and its useless comment process distract us from the real issue, which is that we need to decrease cruise ship traffic in Juneau because the situation is out of control. 


It’s like a house party that’s gotten way out of hand. What started out as a casual gathering with friends has turned into a rager where unwanted strangers are eating all our food, pissing in the sink, and blasting loud music. We've been politely asking them to tone it down, and they keep ignoring us. 


But here's the thing. This is the place we call home. We can tell them to leave any time we want. We don't need to have a polite conversation about minimizing the harm they're causing. We have the right to tell them to get out. 


We’ve been told Juneau can't possibly survive if we so much as attempt to limit cruise ships. 


We’ve been told that our only hope is to mitigate the harm caused by the inevitable and ever-increasing flow of cruise ship traffic.


I don’t buy any of that. 


The cruise industry has been pushing this narrative for decades, and they’ve succeeded in convincing many Juneau residents to believe their lies. 


But not all of us. 


Some of us understand that most of the money from cruise ship passengers goes straight back into corporate bank accounts. We understand that the economic benefits we get from tourists buying a few trinkets at the gift shops do not outweigh the inflated cost of living caused by seasonal employee housing, or the jacked-up rent for genuinely local downtown businesses, or the additional burdens on our city’s infrastructure. 


We understand that Juneau’s economy is diverse and resilient and will not crumble if we limit cruise ships. And we understand that in the long term Juneau’s economy may actually improve with fewer cruise ships, as we build high-value, low-volume tourism opportunities for longer-stay travelers.


Despite the cruise ship industry’s best efforts to convince us otherwise, many of us know that Juneau does not need 1.7-plus million tourists per year to be a thriving community. 


We can stop cruise ship corporations from taking over our community. And we don’t need to wait for a task force — or the corporations — to give us permission. 


What we need is citizen action. We need a new ballot initiative putting enforceable limits on cruise ship passenger numbers. If sleepy little Bar Harbor, Maine, could limit cruise ships, so can we. Even national news outlets can see that we need to set a boundary. 


I suggest we start with a clean 1 million passengers per year. 


One million annual passengers or fewer was plenty to support a thriving Juneau tourism industry for decades (until 2016, when for the first time more than 1 million passengers arrived), but not so much that it overwhelmed our community. We can and should get back to that.  


Predictably, the cruise ship industry will again dump boatloads of money into its pro-tourism propaganda and persuade many Juneauites to vote against their own interests. 


Don’t care. 


The half-dozen wealthy locals who own highly lucrative tourism businesses will cry about how you’ll be harming your neighbors and destroying small businesses. 


Don’t care. 


We need to try. Again, and again, and again. Until we stop corporate greed from infecting every corner of our lives. 


If we don’t, we’ll watch our community be devoured by multinational corporations. And all we’ll have to show for it will be a few strongly-worded emails in our sent folder. 


Enough is enough. It’s time to take real action. 


• Logan Miller is a lifelong Alaskan who was raised in Juneau and lives on North Douglas. He is an attorney, and has also worked in commercial fishing and mining.

Cedar Clinic Ad 1.png
rainbowfoodsad1.png
BFM Digital Ad-1.png
Ramada Ad PDF 7-10-26.png
CBJ Public Notice Web Tile 8.07.2026.png
Trust land office.jpg
Oct.14.png
JPM 2.png
vote ad.png
Holiday Cheer (5).jpg
girl yeti spaceship juneau independent ad 2.jpeg
25HEC053_Radia_Ad_Graphic-Chelsea-300x25
bottom of page